Lagos State Water Corporation Publication of Awarded Contracts - Second National Urban Water Sector Reform Project

Bid/Contract Description: Construction of Treatment Plant at Alexander Avenue
Duration: 24 months
Contract Signature Date: 14th November, 2010

Awarded Bidder
Name & Address: Zakhem Construction Ltd. Pakistan
Bid Price at Bid Opening: NGN 553,176,797.24
Final Bid Price: NGN 552,736,839.00

Evaluated Bidders (NAme of Evaluated Bidders)
1.) Zakhem Construction Ltd. Pakistan
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 553,176,797.24
Bid price of evaluated bid (NGN): 552,736,839.00

2.) SEG MAHSEN & Co (Nig) Ltd
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 577,420,593.83
Bid price of evaluated bid (NGN): 581 ,250,110.50

3.) T. Line Engineering Ltd
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 570,491,334.60
Bid price of evaluated bid (NGN): 571.829.073.60

4.) CGC Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 624,157,497.53
Bid price of evaluated bid (NGN): 620,210,600.97

5.) Naston Engineering Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 305,942,573.75
Bid price of evaluated bid (NGN): 308,931,869.17

6.) Hydro Con & Eng. Nig
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 505,489,501.00
Bid price of evaluated bid (NGN): 497,749,501.00

7.) NAHMAN Construction Co Ltd
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 508,223,280.40
Bid price of evaluated bid (NGN): 500,483,280.00

Rejected Bidders
1.) T. Line Engineering Ltd
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 577,420,593.83
Reasons for Rejection: 6th highest bid and hence was not post qualified

2.) SEG MAHSEN & Co (Nig) Ltd
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 570,491,334.60
Reasons for Rejection: In adequate working capital to execute the contract

3.) CGC Nigeria Limited
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 624,157,497.53
Reasons for Rejection: highest bid and hence was not post qualifIed

4.) Naston Engineering Nig. Limited
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 305,942,573.75
Reasons for Rejection: In adequate annual construction turnover as required; bidder’s about 28 % less than the Engineer’s Estimate

5.) Hydra Con & Eng. Nig
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): 505,489,501.00
Reasons for Rejection: Questionable poor performance experience and lack of adequate requirement of work of similar nature and complexity and inadequate working capital

6.) Hydro Con & Eng. Nig
Bid Price at Opening (NGN): NAHMAN Construction Co Ltd
Reasons for Rejection: Inadequate experience both In similar and general construction; Inadequate qualified key personnel required and Inadequate working capital