Lagos State Water Corporation Publication of Awarded Contracts - Supply of Aluminum Sulphate

Publication of Awarded Contracts

Bid/Contract Description: Supply of Aluminum Sulphate
Duration: 6 Months
Contract Signature Date: 21/12/07

Awarded Bidder(s)
Stonewall Continental Ltd. Nigeria
Bid Price at bid opening: NGN 121,155,000.00
Final Bid Price: NGN 121,155,000.00

Evaluated Bidder(s)
1.) Primal Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 104,428,500.00
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 144,428,500.00

2.) Goodwill Impex International Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): $443,250 + 32,113,462
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): $443,250 + 32,113,462

3.) Intekno Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN):
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN):

4.) Bussdor & Company Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN):
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN):

5.) Montana Industries Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 128,054,000.00
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN):128,054,000.00

6.) Sunshine Oil & Chemical  Development Company Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 137,900,000.00
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 137,900,000.00

7.) Initial Harbour Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 137,730,000.00
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 137,730,000.00
 
8.) Stoneweil Continental Ltd. Nigeria
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 121,155,000.00
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 121,155.000.00

9.) Energy Equipment & Services Ltd.
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): $4,938,873 + N268,177,198
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): $4,938,873 + N268,177,198

10.) Geophil Service Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 167,450,000.00
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN):

Rejected Bidder(s)
1.) Primal Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 104,428,500.00
Reason(s) for Rejection: Sixtth Lowest Bid

2.) Goodwill Impex International Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): $443,250 + 32,113,462
Reason(s) for Rejection: Specifications does not conform with section VI (3) pages 55-57 of Bidding document; No detailed specifications were provided

3.) Intekno Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 0.00
Reason(s) for Rejection: Quality of product to be supplied is in doubt and could not be guaranteed for safety to human health if used in water treatment. No manufacturer’s recommendation that the product is suitable for treating drinking water

4.) Bussdor & Company Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 0.00
Reason(s) for Rejection: Auditor’s report for 3 years (2003 ,2004 & 2005) submitted was not signed by the auditors and therefore cannot be relied upon as true authentic opinion of the auditors. No evidence of previous experience. No evidence that the bidder has access to storage facilities at the port of destination. No evidence of haulage facilities to final destination Included or mentioned.

5.) Montana Industries Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 128,054,000.00
Reason(s) for Rejection: Third lowest bid

6.) Sunshine Oil & Chemical  Development Company Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 137,900,000.00
Reason(s) for Rejection: Fifth lowest bid

7.) Initial Harbour Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 137,730,000.00
Reason(s) for Rejection: Fourth lowest bid

8.) Energy Equipment & Services Ltd.
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): $4,938,873 + N268,177,198
Reason(s) for Rejection: Highest Bid

9.) Geophil Service Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 167,450,000.00
Reason(s) for Rejection: Seventh lowest bid