Publication of Award of Contract for Construction of New Treatment Plant at Isheri Oke

Publication of Awarded Contracts

Bid/Contract Description: Construction of New Treatment Plant at Isheri Oke
Duration: 30 Months
Contract Signature Date: 46/08/10

Awarded Bidder(s)
CGC Nigeria Ltd, China
Bid Price at bid opening: NGN653,913,070.7
Final Bid Price: NGN649,041,024.10

Evaluated Bidder(s)
1.) CGC Nigeria Ltd, China 
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 653,913,070.07
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 649,041,024.10

2.) RASIO Technical Services Limited
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 378,197,409.70
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 314,533,409.70

3.) NASTON Engineering Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 259,440,965.73
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 187,066,518.06

4.) CONSOLIDATED Contractors Ltd, Nigeria
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 365,891,788.15
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 293,691,788.15

5.) SEG. MAHSEN & Co. (Nig) Limited
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 448,962,263.75
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 338,544,497.93

6.) HYDRO Construction & Engineering Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 690,352,905.00
Bid Price of Evaluated (NGN): 618,152,905.00

Rejected Bidder(s)
1.) RASIO Technical Services Limited
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 378,197,409.70
Reason(s) for Rejection: - Inadequate Construction Turnover Capacity In the last five years
- Inadequate Experience as Prime Contractor in works of similar nature and complexity (178 Sub-Cl. 5.Sb)
- Inadequate relevant key personnel experience in works of similar nature and complexity (ITS Sub CI. 5.Sd)
- Poorly presentation of work methodology and programme demonstrating poor understanding of the entailed work demand

2.) NASTON Engineering Nigeria Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 259,440,965.73
Reason(s) for Rejection: Inadequate turnover to meet requirement to qualify for the contract award; Bid price 30% lower than Engineer’s estimate

3.) CONSOLIDATED Contractors Ltd, Nigeria
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 365,891,788.15
Reason(s) for Rejection: Inadequate Experience in works of similar nature and complexity; false claim of commitment work experience inadequate key personnel proposed for the contract as required

4.) SEG. MAHSEN & Co. (Nig) Limited
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 448,962,263.75
Reason(s) for Rejection: Inadequate Annual Turnover for further award of any Contract

5.) HYDRO Construction & Engineering Ltd
Bid Price at bid opening (NGN): 690,352,905.00
Reason(s) for Rejection: Questionable poor performance experience and lack of adequate requirement of work of similar nature and complexity and; inadequate working capital specified as requirement for the successful implementation of the contract 9ITB sub-clause 5.5(e)